Copy
and paste a quote from each the readings that caused you to have a strong
reaction (agreement, disagreement, confusion...) and explain your reaction.
According
to “Lunsford, the writing we produce is not getting worse. Instead, it is simply adapting to the modern
world.”
There
is so much social media going on today with the student culture that writing or
how they write seems to be a matter of preference in my opinion. When students
are texting it’s up to them how they want to convey their messages to each
other or to their instructors. My personal preferences are I don’t really like
abbreviation if at all possible. I would rather send you a message with correct
spelling and correct grammar.
I
understand that writing can be depicted as a plastic art but there still has to
be a fine line where the language is understandable and the message makes
sense. With so many different social media options we sometimes find ourselves
with a limited amount of characters however, that does not mean that we cannot
send out a well written sentence that can communicate our message. In our
reading it was stated that “student writing provide the ability to marry text
and other media in ways that can often help them provide greater depth and
texture to what they are trying to communicate.” I totally agree with this
statement after all words and pictures say a great deal together.
Then
state where do you stand on the continuum between Web Evangelist (Digital media
is changing the way people read and write in the Digital Age) and
Traditionalist (digital media are destroying our children ability to read and
write)?
My
stand is that yes digital media is changing the way kids are reading today,
some may be reading comic books, novels, or fan fiction. The bottom line is
they are reading and that is what is important. How can we expect students to
keep up in the competitive world of digital media if they are not using it?
Digital media in not going away if anything it is evolving all the time and as
educators we must adapt at all cost or we will not be able to keep up with the
demand to help the students.
As
for the writing well, I remember when I was in school and I had to do
penmanship everyday it was to help teach us cursive and make our writing
neater. That no longer exist in our school no big deal was made about losing it.
Back then all we had was simple pencil, paper and a dictionary to make sure
your spelling was correct. Writing in the digital age has changed that, it has
managed to put the way we read and write into a different form so that we can
communicate efficiently and effectively. I do feel that both of the articles
had good and valid points and opinions. We still have so much to learn and
writing guide line are needed.
Professors,
Researchers, and Society will always agree to disagree when it comes to what
works and what doesn’t, it’s the nature of the beast. I disagree that digital
media is destroying the ability to read and write.
Justify
your stance using evidence from each of the readings. If you can't find evidence in the readings to
support your stance then find another online article to provide supporting
evidence for your stance on the effects of digital media and young people's
reading and writing abilities and link to the online article that supports your
stance.
Based on both articles I felt that
they both had very good argument in stating their case. I can’t say that either
one of them had concrete statistical evidence based on what I read. I think that looking for evidence on the
effects of digital media and young people's reading and writing abilities is
still to premature. I did find this article online Literacy learning and
technology I thought it had some interesting information and it actually had
some data and statistics.
One of which was a polling of
knowledge and the sharing of common goals and problem solving and how it will
be at the core of classroom practices. The 2005 study conducted by the Pew Internet
and American Life project (Lenhart & Madden, 2005) claim that 57% of the
teens using the Internet could be considered media creators. Meaning that these
students created a blog, webpage, posted original artwork, photography, stories
or videos online or remixed online content into their own creations. Material
that requires reading and writing.
However research contends that there
is a partition between the technology that is used in everyday life and that is
used in many classroom settings (Dede, 2005). The limited access to digital
media, technologies and Internet filtering in schools can still constrain the
possible links between students’ real worlds and classroom practices. This is
why more research is needed in the field of the effects of digital media and young
people's reading and writing abilities. We need to know the age categories of
effects if any, are girls affect more than boys, and how as educators do we
prepare students ethically to read and write in an appropriate internet
language.
Create
a Visual Metaphor that reflects your stance on the effects of digital media on
young people's abilities to read and write.
http://www.curriculumsupport.education.nsw.gov.au/literacy/assets/pdf/packages/tech_lit_learn.pdf
